Skip to content
YibudYibud

Startup MRI

Startup Idea Evaluator — Score Your Idea in 60 Seconds

Comparing two or more ideas? The evaluator puts every candidate through the same seven dimensions, the same five inputs and the same weights, so what you are comparing is the idea, not the order you filled the form in. Free, no signup, under 60 seconds.

Last updated · November 20, 2026

Quick answer

What is a startup idea evaluator?

A startup idea evaluator is built for the decision between options: which of these should I test first. Startup MRI scores seven dimensions (validation, market demand, competition, distribution, monetization, build difficulty and founder fit) from five structured inputs, using a deterministic rule engine, so two ideas run on the same day with the same inputs are measured on identical terms. The comparison only holds while the conditions stay identical: the same date, the same five inputs, the same engine version, one difference at a time. What it cannot settle is the part no form can capture, such as whether you can personally sell this one. The report arrives in under 60 seconds, free, with no signup.

Key takeaways

What a startup idea evaluator does, in plain language

  • Comparison is the evaluator's job. A single score says little on its own; two scores produced on the same terms show you exactly where the ideas differ.
  • Keep the conditions identical. Same day, same five inputs, same engine version, and change one thing at a time, or you are comparing how carefully each idea was written down.
  • Read the two halves separately. Four dimensions describe the market, two describe whether you can ship and sell, and validation sits in front of both, so a single average hides which half is weak.
  • Break ties with the cheapest test, not the higher score. When two candidates land in the same place, start with the one whose critical assumption is cheaper to check.
  • The ranking is a snapshot. Re-run both candidates after new evidence and expect the order to change; the change is the signal, not the first ranking.

Comparison framework

Idea strength vs. execution readiness

Two kinds of risk. Four ways to choose. Before you run another validation experiment, decide whether your biggest risk is the idea or the execution — and what to do once you can see it.

Why the dimensions split into two stacks

Idea-side risk and execution-side risk are different problems

CB Insights' recurring post-mortem analyses of failed startups have placed "no market need" and "not the right team" among the top failure causes across reports — typically as the two largest categories in both the original sample and the 2024 update of 431 cases. Steve Blank's customer-development framing makes the same point: a startup is a chain of hypotheses, half about the market and half about the team. The evaluator's seven dimensions follow that split. The four market-side dimensions — market demand, competition, distribution, monetization — test whether the market is real and reachable at the chosen price. The two execution-side dimensions — build difficulty, founder fit — test whether the founder can ship and sell it. The seventh, validation, sits in front of all of them and asks whether any of it has been checked. Treating the seven as one undifferentiated risk is the most common mistake when evaluating an idea for the first time.

The four decision quadrants

Combining the two stacks into a 2 × 2 map

Place the idea on the grid: idea strength on one axis, execution readiness on the other. Each quadrant implies a different next action.

Strong idea · Weak execution fit

Co-found or pass

The market is real, but the founder does not have the skills, time, or audience to reach it at the chosen price. The honest next actions are: find a co-founder who covers the missing execution piece, narrow the build scope so execution fits the founder, or pass on this idea. Idea-side strength does not rescue execution-side weakness.

Strong idea · Strong execution fit

Build now

Both stacks are aligned. The next move is to pick the single critical assumption — usually the lowest-scoring dimension — and run the cheapest experiment that produces a behavior signal. Avoid the temptation to "one more dimension check"; the alignment is the signal.

Weak idea · Weak execution fit

Skip

Both stacks are weak. The founder's time, the founder's audience, and the chosen market all point away from this idea. The honest next action is to pick a different one. The 2 × 2 is most useful here — it gives the founder permission to move on without wondering whether one more dimension would have changed the read.

Weak idea · Strong execution fit

Reposition

The founder has the skills, time, or audience, but the chosen idea is too small or too crowded to be worth them. The next actions are: a different niche, a sharper angle, or a different idea entirely. Founder expertise does not rescue a market that cannot support the chosen monetization at the named price.

Comparing two or three candidate ideas

How to use the grid to choose between ideas

Run each candidate idea through Startup MRI in turn. For each, compute two aggregate reads: the average of the four idea-side dimensions and the average of the two execution-side dimensions, and keep the validation score outside both axes. Place each candidate on the grid. The strongest combined outcome — strong idea, strong execution — is the one to start with. When two candidates tie, the differentiator is usually the cheapest critical assumption to test, not the overall score.

How to act

How to act on the 2 × 2 result

Knowing your quadrant is the first step. The next step is to commit to a concrete sequence of actions with a rough timeframe, before the read goes stale.

  1. Quadrant 1

    Build now

    1. Lock the critical assumption

      The report's lowest-scoring dimension is the one whose failure would invalidate the rest of the plan. Write it on a sticky note. Everything else is secondary.

    2. Run the cheapest behavior-signal test

      One to two weeks. A problem interview, a landing page priced at the planned tier, or a 30-day concierge — whichever produces evidence fastest at the named buyer. Do not ship the full MVP yet.

    3. Set a 30-day shipping milestone

      Pick the smallest shippable slice of the MVP that produces customer value. Lock a date. The milestone forces scope discipline; without it, founder time tends to leak.

  2. Quadrant 2

    Co-found or pass

    1. Name the missing execution piece

      One to two days. The missing skill, the missing time, the missing audience. Write it down. Vague gaps are impossible to fill; named gaps can be filled or passed.

    2. Search for a co-founder who covers that piece

      One to two months. A founder who already has credibility in the missing domain — they will not need to be sold on the problem. Avoid generalists; this is the place for a specialist.

    3. If no co-founder is found, narrow the build scope

      A smaller version of the same idea, built in a week or two with tools you already know, is better than a six-month build that needs the missing skill.

    4. If neither works, pass

      Idea-side strength does not rescue execution-side weakness. The 2 × 2 has given you permission to move on.

  3. Quadrant 3

    Reposition

    1. Identify the weakest idea-side dimension

      Usually one of: market demand (the buyer is too small), competition (the angle is not sharp enough), distribution (the channel does not match), or monetization (the business model does not produce revenue at the named price).

    2. Try two or three alternative niches or angles

      One week each. A different segment, a sharper wedge, a higher price tier. Each repositioning test is one week of founder time plus the inputs the engine can re-score.

    3. Pick the angle that scores highest on the idea-side dimensions

      Re-run Startup MRI on each alternative. The one with the highest aggregate of the four idea-side dimensions is the one worth pursuing.

    4. If still weak, choose a different idea

      Founder expertise does not rescue a market that cannot support the chosen monetization at the named price. Your time is worth a real market.

  4. Quadrant 4

    Skip

    1. Do not re-run the validator hoping for a different result

      The score is a function of the inputs. If the inputs have not changed, the score will not either.

    2. Use the 2 × 2 to evaluate the next idea

      The grid is the cheapest way to know whether the next idea sits in the 'Build now' quadrant or another one — before you invest the time.

    3. Move on

      The 2 × 2 has given you permission to skip. Use it. The next idea deserves the same structured read.

When to stop

Re-run the grid after each decision produces evidence

The grid is a snapshot, not a verdict. Re-run it after each action sequence above produces evidence — the per-dimension shifts tell you whether the idea is strengthening or weakening, and whether the quadrant placement has changed.

Same-terms comparison

Fill the same six lines for every candidate

This is the whole method. Write one column per idea, fill the six rows below, and do it in a single sitting. Every row is either a number the evaluator already produces or one fact about the cheapest test, so the table takes minutes, not an afternoon.

  1. The date, once for the whole table

    Run every candidate on the same day. Inputs written on Monday and Thursday are not comparable, because the engine reads the words you had that week.

  2. One sentence each, written the same way

    Same length, same shape: who the customer is and what they stop doing wrong. A longer sentence is a different input, not a better idea.

  3. The same five structured inputs

    Idea, target audience, monetization model, acquisition channel, and technical background. Fill them the same way for every candidate, including the ones you like less.

  4. Seven dimension scores, side by side

    Overall is the summary. The seven sub-scores are the comparison, and the columns that differ are where the two ideas are actually different ideas.

  5. The critical assumption each idea hinges on

    The report names one per analysis. Two different assumptions between candidates are usually a stronger signal than a ten-point gap in the overall score.

  6. Cheapest test, and the evidence already in hand

    Cost, time, and what behaviour you have already seen. Evidence counts only as behaviour: payment, sign-up that turns into use, time given, referrals.

What the table cannot settle

It cannot compare what you did not write down: your access to the buyers, your tolerance for a two-year sales cycle, or whether you will still care about this in March. It also cannot weigh two ideas that need different engines of trust, such as a paid tool against a regulated one. Use the table to choose which idea to test first. Do not use it to declare the other one dead.

Two saved analyses can be placed side by side without rebuilding either one.

Compare two saved analyses

How it works

How Startup MRI evaluates ideas

Seven dimensions the evaluator scores. The numbers come from a deterministic rule engine, so the same engine version and inputs produce the same scores, while the explanation text may vary.

  • Dimension 1

    Market demand

    Is there real demand for what you want to build? The evaluator looks at the size and reachability of the target audience and the strength of the workarounds people already use. A large market with weak workarounds scores high; a small market with strong incumbents scores low.

  • Dimension 2

    Competition

    How saturated is the market you are entering? The evaluator considers the number of direct competitors, how well-funded they are, and how differentiated the planned product is. A crowded market with a sharp angle still scores well; a crowded market with no angle does not.

  • Dimension 3

    Distribution

    Can the founder actually reach the buyer? The evaluator scores the chosen acquisition channel against the named target audience. SEO plus a content lead magnet is one profile; cold outreach to a niche B2B segment is another. The two are not interchangeable.

  • Dimension 4

    Monetization

    Does the business model produce revenue at the chosen price? The evaluator looks at the monetization model (subscription, freemium, one-time, ads, marketplace take rate) and the willingness-to-pay signal for that model in the chosen market.

  • Dimension 5

    Build difficulty

    How long will the MVP take, and what skills does it require? The evaluator scores the technical depth of the planned product and the founder's technical background against each other. A non-technical founder building an AI infrastructure product is a different signal than the same founder building a no-code tool.

  • Dimension 6

    Founder fit

    Does the founder's skills, time, and existing audience match the work? The evaluator scores the fit between the founder and the planned product. A domain expert with a deep network in the target market scores well; a first-time founder with no audience scores the inverse.

Who it's for

Built for founders evaluating before they build

Four personas the evaluator is written for, each with a different set of assumptions to test first.

  • First-time founders

    First-time founders

    You have an idea but no prior reference for what a 'good' idea looks like. The evaluator gives you a structured, repeatable read on whether the idea is worth the next three to six months of your time.

  • Indie hackers

    Indie hackers and side-project builders

    You have 5–10 hours a week and a strong preference for not wasting either. The evaluator gives you a 60-second read on whether the idea is worth the next month, and surfaces the one assumption most worth testing first.

  • Startup teams

    Startup teams choosing between ideas

    You have two or three candidate ideas and limited runway. The evaluator scores each one across the same seven dimensions, so the team can compare them on a like-for-like basis rather than on gut feel.

  • Non-technical

    Non-technical and no-code founders

    The report is written in plain language and explains what every score means. You do not need a data or engineering background to use it. The output is a decision, not a number.

Why evaluate

Why evaluate a startup idea before building it

The expensive choice is usually not how to build an idea, it is which idea to build. Most solo founders do not fail on a feature; they spend six months on the wrong business while the second idea stays in the notes.

  1. Reason 1

    Rank the options without a coin flip

    Two ideas written in the same week are hard to order from memory. Put both through the same seven dimensions on the same day and the difference stops being a feeling. It has a dimension, a score, and a next test attached to it.

  2. Reason 2

    Identify the assumptions your plan most depends on

    Every startup is a chain of assumptions. Evaluation surfaces the chain and names the single critical assumption — the one whose failure would invalidate the rest of the plan. Testing that one assumption first is the highest-leverage activity a founder can run.

  3. Reason 3

    Prioritize the cheapest validation experiments

    Not every assumption deserves a six-month build. Evaluation tells you which assumption to test first and which experiment is cheapest to run. A landing page, a problem interview, or a 30-day concierge is usually enough to produce evidence before any code is written.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions about startup idea evaluation

Short answers, in the same vocabulary the Startup Validation hub uses. Longer answers live in the linked articles.

How do you evaluate a startup idea?
Run a free Startup MRI evaluation first — it scores your idea across 7 dimensions in under 60 seconds. Then run five problem interviews using the Mom Test script from the Startup Validation hub, and confirm willingness to pay with a small pricing experiment. Evaluation is a sequence of cheap tests, not a single event.
What makes a startup idea valuable?
A valuable startup idea passes four tests: the problem is real and felt (people have already built workarounds), the customer is reachable (you can name a channel they actually use), the willingness to pay is concrete (people trade real money for the workaround), and the founder can execute (the founder has the skills, the time, or the audience to ship). Startup MRI scores all four and names the one that is weakest.
Can AI evaluate startup ideas?
AI can produce a structured report that names the assumptions most worth testing next. The scores themselves come from a deterministic rule engine, not from a language model — the same engine version and inputs produce the same scores, while the explanation text may vary. The accuracy of the report is in its structure, not in its prediction of outcomes. The output is a list of risks and the assumption most worth testing next, not a verdict.
Is startup evaluation necessary?
Evaluation is not required, but it is the cheapest insurance a founder can buy. A six-month build that nobody asked for costs the entire runway. A two-week evaluation costs the founder's time and produces a clear go / no-go signal. The cost of skipping evaluation is paid later, in the form of a launch that does not convert.
How accurate are startup evaluation tools?
A startup evaluation tool is accurate at producing a structured report; it is not accurate at predicting whether the startup will succeed. The scores come from a deterministic rule engine so the same engine version and inputs produce the same scores, while the explanation text may vary. Treat the report as a list of risks and the assumption most worth testing next — not as a verdict on the idea.
What is the difference between a startup idea evaluator and a startup idea validator?
The two terms describe the same activity from different angles. 'Validator' emphasizes the test: does the idea pass the four named tests (problem, customer, willingness to pay, founder execution)? 'Evaluator' emphasizes the score: how does the idea rate across the seven dimensions? Yibud ships both, and the underlying engine is identical. The choice of label is a matter of vocabulary, not a difference in capability.
What should I do after evaluating my startup idea?
Read the report's top three risks. Pick the single critical assumption named in the report. Run the cheapest experiment that tests that assumption — usually a problem interview, a landing page, or a 30-day concierge. The evaluation produces a list; the experiment produces evidence; the evidence is what you act on.
How long does it take to evaluate a startup idea?
A free Startup MRI evaluation takes about five minutes and produces a 7-dimension report. The full sequence — interviews, landing page, pricing experiment, 30-day concierge — takes two to six weeks. The evaluation is the first five minutes; the sequence is the next two to six weeks.
How do I compare two startup ideas side by side?
Run each candidate through the evaluator. Aggregate the four idea-side dimensions (market, competition, distribution, monetization) into one read, and the two execution-side dimensions (build difficulty, founder fit) into another. The 2 × 2 deliberately leaves validation out of both axes — it is the heaviest of the seven, so read it on its own. Place each idea on the grid above. The strongest combined outcome — strong idea, strong execution — is the one to start with. The second idea's quadrant usually tells you which dimension to sharpen before circling back.

What you receive

What's in every Startup MRI evaluation

The headline sections in plain language, with every score traceable to a specific fired rule in the rule engine.

  • Seven dimension scores, plus two composites

    Validation, market demand, competition, distribution, monetization, build difficulty and founder fit, each on a 0–100 scale, combined into a weighted overall score and an unweighted opportunity average.

  • Per-dimension breakdown

    Every dimension comes with a short plain-language explanation of what raised or lowered the score, so you know which assumption to test first.

  • Three top risks

    The three risks most likely to invalidate the plan, each with a named failure mode and a recommended experiment.

  • MVP blueprint

    A small list of features to build first, a list to skip, and a complexity estimate.

  • First-customer plan

    The recommended acquisition channel, why it was chosen, and a 4-step plan you can run in the first 6 weeks.

Limitations

What a Startup MRI evaluation is not

The honest list, so you do not mistake the report for something it is not.

  • It does not predict whether your startup will succeed. No tool can. Treat the report as a list of risks and the assumption most worth testing next — not as a verdict.
  • It does not replace customer conversations. The report identifies assumptions; the conversations produce evidence.
  • It is not a market-research report. The engine has no live data feeds; the scores come from the inputs the founder typed in.
  • It is not personalised advice. The recommendations are calibrated to the founder's inputs and a small set of named defaults — not to a founder's specific industry or geography.

Evaluate your startup idea with Startup MRI

Five short questions. A structured 7-dimension report in under 60 seconds — free to read, with the execution kit as a one-time $2.99. No signup, and the same engine version and inputs produce the same scores, while the explanation text may vary.

Not sure which entry point you need? Use the validator to find the next test to run, or the score calculator to see how the number is produced and how to read it.